Living At the Water’s Edge: Reviving the Gomti Riverfront with a Nature-Based Design Approach (Case Study)

Author: Mitali Kumar
Modern Development is said to be synonymous with the use of concrete (Watts, 2019). Developments in India post-90s saw a boost in the material in the building and construction industry (Tappin, 2002). Unfortunately, natural ecosystems like rivers were also impacted by this phenomenon, the concretisation of River Gomti in Lucknow being a prime case example. The Gomti River today is managed as per the needs of its dependents and tamed as required by grey infrastructure systems like dams, barrages, and channelized water edges in the name of risk reduction. 
To maintain a healthy river ecosystem, rivers need to have continuous flow and the potential to flood (Talbot, et al., 2018). With alterations in the river’s flow pattern and reduced connection with its immediate floodplain, Gomti is now a linear entity: a mere channel rather than the dynamic riverine landscape that it used to be. 
Planning along the sensitive river corridor needs to have a holistic understanding of the river ecosystem. How does the river function? What does the river provide, and how do our actions impact it? Can one work with the natural system rather than attempting to control it? (Li et al., 2016).
One way of efficiently assessing the natural river ecosystem is by understanding the river connectivity at the catchment scale and by studying the elements that constitute river health. A river’s connectivity can be described in three dimensions within the river corridor and the watershed, namely (Wohl, 2017):
1. Lateral (riparian areas: wetlands/floodplain/lakes)
2. Vertical (atmosphere/groundwater)
3. Longitudinal (connectivity between upstream and downstream: canals & tributaries)

Figure 1: Three-Dimensional Connectivity of the River Water System | Source: Author

The Gomti along with these connected water systems in the catchment offers several ecosystem services – benefits and resources for communities and biodiversity.

Figure 3: Ecosystem Services offered by River Gomti | Source: Author

As an Urban entity, the Gomti water system is not just a resource but also a high-value real estate, with mass-scale developments (both urban and agricultural) developing increasingly near these sensitive ecosystems. Over time with development and rising population, the demand for the ecosystem has disproportionately risen to more than what it can provide. 

 

The ecosystem services offered by the Gomti watershed in Lucknow today are impacted by several anthropogenic activities, to name a few: 
Gomti Catchment Water System (Issues in Lucknow)
Lateral Connectivity
Lake (IANS, 2019)
Wetland (Sharda, 2020)
Floodplain (Shah, 2008)
Issues
Lost Reclaimed, 
Divided, Concretized edges
Farmers, Developers, Government, Livestock, Residents, Visitors
Lost, Reclaimed & concretized 
Contamination by use of fertilisers Overgrazing, Dumping of domestic waste
Responsible Stakeholders
Farmers, Developers, Government
Farmers, Developers, Government, Livestock, Residents, Visitors
Farmers, Developers, Government, Livestock, Washermen, Residents, Visitors
Impact on Ecosystem Services
Reduced Water Security, 
Reduced Food Security
Lost habitats 
Biodiversity Loss
Reduced Water Security, 
Reduced Food Security
Lost habitats 
Biodiversity Loss
Water Contamination
Reduced Water Security, 
Reduced Food Security
Lost habitats 
Biodiversity Loss
Water Contamination
Impact on Gomti River
Increased Water Demand
Increased Water Demand
Contaminated Water
Biodiversity Loss 
Decreased River width, increased speed of flow 
Vertical Connectivity
Rain (PTI, 2022)
Groundwater (Times News Network, 2022)
Issues
Changed Precipitation Patterns 
Stormwater run-off
Over-exploited 
Hampered recharge due to increased impervious surfaces
Responsible Stakeholders
Global Climatic Factors, Mankind
Farmers, Developers, Government, Residents
Impact on Ecosystem Services
Drought 
Flood Hazard
Reduced Water Security, 
Water Contamination
Impact on Gomti River
Reduced Recharge
Flooding in storm events
Increased Siltation
Biodiversity Loss 
Reduced Recharge, 
Loss of water to replenish groundwater 
Biodiversity Loss
Longitudinal Connectivity
Canals & Tributaries (Lucknow News, 2021).
Issues
Lost Reclaimed, Divided, Concretized edges, Contaminated
Responsible Stakeholders
Farmers, Developers, Government, Residents
Impact on Ecosystem Services
Reduced Water Security,
Reduced Food Security
Lost Habitats Biodiversity Loss 
Water Contamination
Impact on Gomti River
Increased Water Demand
Contaminated Water 
Biodiversity Loss 

Figure 4: The Urban Water Cycle: Lost Connections of River Gomti | Source: Author

The spatial connectivity in the river watershed impacts the response of rivers to natural and human disturbances. Urban development patterns in the city have led to fragmentation and disconnection in the natural river connectivity, which impacts flood/drought regulation, diminishing water security. Also, contamination in the lateral connectivity of the river amplifies issues, like pollution, by the time they reach the river from their source, impacting ecological health. The exploitation of the natural water system to meet the rising demands of the urban population, and unsustainable practices along the fertile floodplain can be said to be the root causes of the ailing ecosystem. 
Ensuring connectivity in the urban water system in Lucknow is crucial in restoring the river Gomti; however, the appreciation of the interdependency of these systems is insufficiently considered in urban planning policies. 
Furthermore, the infrastructure of convenience has led to a reduced significance of these landscapes of necessities. The use of concrete in construction across the city of Lucknow incidentally also marks the detachment of the community from the Gomti watershed. Ease and availability of resources to the population(be it for domestic/commercial/institutional use) leads to overlooking how they are a part of the exploitation of the natural resource. The cosmetic beautification of the Gomti floodplains in the name of restoration by concretizing the eco-sensitive riverbanks is another example of human insensitivity to the ecosystem (Prasad, 2018).  
Riverfront Parks have immense potential to work with the riverine landscape: for enhancing the deteriorating ecosystem while educating the people about the same. Existing at the culmination of urban life and water, these eco-fragile nodes now need to be multifaceted to meet the growing demands of the ecosystem, while making efforts to conserve it.  It is imperative to trace back old legacies instigating responsible stewardship and adopting nature-based solutions.
Before Pucca systems of construction, we depended on the rivers and lakes at a more intimate level. The silt was manually excavated to cover houses for cooling in the summers. Recharge wells were maintained in each household, where the consumption was altered as per water availability. With Borewells, one is not aware of how much water one utilizes. –Brajendra Pal, Lok Bharti(personal communication)
Nature-Based Solutions as defined by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN), aim to incorporate natural processes, low-cost, and sustainable methods to cater to socio-environmental challenges (IUCN, n.d.). Designing from nature as a method of environmental conversation has been adopted by indigenous people, even before scientific research had deemed them relevant. The locals whose livelihoods depend on these rivers, the government, and private bodies involved in these developments, and the people who visit these attractions: all form a network of stakeholders that are the essence of any Nature-based intervention. Hence, these solutions strive to be inclusive, made with informed choices, such that the benefits are equally distributed–for the people and the environment. 
Gorakhpur, a town near Lucknow, boasts a success story of efficient ecosystem revival through responsible stewardship by incorporating Nature-Based Solutions (Du, 2019 ). This approach, if tailor-made for the Gomti River Basin, seems viable. Civil society organisations like Lok Bharti are making efforts in Lucknow City to bring back natural systems and by community actions, like
1. River cleaning at Gaughat; the ghat where the river enters Lucknow; by local communities for religious bathing. (The Times News Network, 2022)
2. Revival of ponds & small rivers in the Gomti Watershed for Jal Utsav, (Times News Network, 2022)
3. Education for farmers for sustainable resource management: organic farming, water-sensitive crop selection & livestock-centric farming. 

Figure 5: Community efforts to reconnect to old natural ways | Source: (Lok Bharti, 2022)

However, for these efforts to have an impact on the broader Gomti River System: holistic catchment-centric planning and mass execution of Nature-Based Solutions by involving local communities is the need of the hour. 
Acknowledgment
Special thanks to Venkatesh Dutta (BBAU), Brajendra Pal (Lok Bharti), Farrukh Khan (Water Aid), and Farhad Contractor; for their input and guidance throughout the project.
Works Cited
Du, J. (2019, October 9). In Gorakhpur, India, Citizens Use Nature to Prevent Floods. Retrieved from World Resources Institute: https://www.wri.org/insights/gorakhpur-india-citizens-use-nature-prevent-floods
IANS. (2019, July 8). Lucknow loses almost half its water bodies to builders. Retrieved from India Tv : https://www.indiatvnews.com/news/india-water-pollution-water-bodies-in-lucknow-land-grabbing-construction-533597
IUCN. (n.d.). Nature-based Solutions. Retrieved from IUCN: https://www.iucn.org/our-work/nature-based-solutions
Li, Y., Tickner, D., Cao, J., & Sayers, P. (2016). River restoration: A strategic approach to planning and management. Paris, France: United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/350966763
Lok Bharti. (2022, December ). Patrika. Retrieved from Lok Samman: https://loksamman.in/
Lucknow News. (2021, April 1). 22 Gomti tributaries have almost dried up, no flow left in four: Expert’s report. Retrieved from Hindustan Times: https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/lucknow-news/22-gomti-tributaries-have-almost-dried-up-no-flow-left-in-four-expert-s-report-101617300898939.html
Prasad, R. (2018, May 17). Gomti River and Gomti Riverfront Lucknow – Analysis on Restoration and Development. Retrieved from Ballot Box India: https://ballotboxindia.com/ap/gomti-river-riverfront-lucknow/5182018549/
PTI. (2022, October 9). Deficient monsoon and excess rains afterward, Uttar Pradesh farmers stare at heavy losses. Retrieved from The Hindu: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/deficient-monsoon-and-excess-rains-afterwards-uttar-pradesh-farmers-stare-at-heavy-losses/article65987661.ece
Shah, P. (2008, December 21). Govt reclaims Gomti’s flood plain. Retrieved from The Times of India: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/lucknow/govt-reclaims-gomtis-flood-plain/articleshow/3868226.cms
Sharda, S. (2020, February 28). Wetland in Lucknow backyard wallows, chokes on pollution. Retrieved from Times of India: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/lucknow/wetland-in-lucknow-backyard-wallows-chokes-on-pollution/articleshow/74348817.cms
Talbot, C. J., Bennett, E. M., Cassell, K., Hanes, D. M., Minor, E. C., Paerl, H., . . . Xenopoulos, M. A. (2018, May 11). The impact of flooding on aquatic ecosystem services. Biogeochemistry, 141, 439–461. doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/s10533-018-0449-7
Tappin, S. (2002). The Early Use of Reinforced Concrete in India. Construction History, 78-98.
The Times News Network (TNN). (2022, September 30). Gaughat where Gomti enters Lucknow to get park. Retrieved from The Times of India: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/lucknow/gaughat-where-gomti-enters-city-to-get-park/articleshow/94547901.cms
Times News Network. (2022, April 22 ). Lucknow stares at critical groundwater level. Retrieved from The Times of India: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/lucknow/city-stares-at-critical-groundwater-level/articleshow/90990878.cms
Times News Network. (2022, April 16). Revival of 2,000 ponds to swell up ailing Gomti river. Retrieved from The Times of India: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/lucknow/revival-of-2000-ponds-to-swell-up-ailing-gomti-river/articleshow/90870335.cms
Watts, J. (2019, February 25). Concrete: the most destructive material on Earth. Retrieved from The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/feb/25/concrete-the-most-destructive-material-on-earth
Wohl, E. (2017). Connectivity in rivers. Progress in Physical Geography, 345-362. doi:10.1177/0309133317714972