India’s Approach to Data Decolonisation: Moving Away from the “Data as Resource” Metaphor

ABSTRACT

This paper critically examines India’s data governance framework and its geopolitical dimension. It does so specifically within the context of standard-setting frameworks of the United States, the European Union, and China. These frameworks conceptualise data as a resource and revenue-generating economic asset. This work argues that while the Indian government has been vocal about data sovereignty and combatting data colonialism, it carries the “data as resource” metaphor into its policy framework. Adopting this metaphor perpetuates the economic dimension of data colonialism, which involves big tech companies profiting by extracting and monopolising people’s data. Moreover, this paper argues that to combat data colonialism, the Indian emphasis on data sovereignty must not focus only on the state’s sovereignty but on the people who generate data. Focusing on people’s sovereignty over their data would entail being attentive to data’s social characteristics and moving the foundations of policy away from the “data as resource” metaphor. Innovating data governance from this perspective would entail a more comprehensive data decolonisation, making India a standard-setter in its own right.

KEYWORDS: Data Governance, Data Colonialism, Data Sovereignty, Data as Resource, Strategic Autonomy 

 

INTRODUCTION 

Data governance refers to governmental and inter-governmental regulations about collecting, storing, transferring and using digital data. It is necessary because “data in digital form are [sic] routinely created, gathered, and shared across the globe to support core societal functions, including healthcare systems, transportation, international commerce, and national security” (Arner et al., 2021). Governments thus consider digital data a valuable asset. Its flow must be regulated to benefit the citizens and their economies (Ciuriak, 2022). 

This paper argues that India’s current stance on data governance carries a ‘data as resource’ mindset that current standard-setters in the field, such as the US, the EU, and China, have adopted. This mindset perpetuates data colonialism of tech companies over people’s data. The paper then argues that there is a need to shift to being attentive to data’s social characteristics. Moreover, while India emphasises data sovereignty, this paper argues that to combat data colonialism, emphasis on data sovereignty must not focus only on the state’s sovereignty but on the people who generate data. Innovating data governance from this perspective provides India with a window to become a standard setter in its own right.


Default Author Image

Mihir Kaulgud

Default Author Image

Riya Singh Rathore

Found this post insightful? Share it with your network and help spread the knowledge.

Suggested Reads

India’s and Other Emerging Carbon Markets in the Developing World

Abstract Exactly 28 years ago, with the Kyoto Protocol; a result of the Earth Summit held at Rio De Janeiro in Brazil, carbon markets came into existence to address climate change, and it established the foundation for carbon markets by introducing market-based mechanisms like emissions trading. Carbon markets allow countries to trade emission reduction credits, […]

Urban Utopias, Ecological Dystopias: The Yamuna Riverfront and Its Discontents

In 2019, the NGT banned all farming activities on the Yamuna floodplains following a study by the National Environmental Engineering Research Institute that found high levels of lead in vegetables and corresponding soil samples. Environmentalists are increasingly suggesting that farming does not threaten the region’s ecology, especially with the controlled use of fertilisers and pesticides

Workers or Owners? The Case of Women Farmers in India

Introduction Marginalization of women, seen through the case of exclusion from ownership structures, can be considered as one of the key reasons against which the suffrage movement was initially mounted, globally. However, in India and abroad, with the delinkages between citizenship rights and property holdings by the mid-twentieth century, the question of land rights and […]

बुलडोजर से अन्याय

आपराधिक मामलों के अभियुक्तों के मकान पर बुलडोजर चलाने की कार्रवाई ने देश के कानून के सामने नई चुनौती पेश की है। कानूनी प्रक्रिया का पालन किए बिना किसी की छत को कैसे ढहाया जा सकता है? अभियुक्त तो दूर यदि किसी को मुकदमे के बाद दोषी भी पाया गया है, तो क्या उसके मकान […]