Stubble Burning: The Need for a Behavioural Lens

ABSTRACT

The open incineration of paddy crop residue, or stubble burning, in the north Indian states of Punjab and Haryana has become a
recurring issue every winter. As pollution caused by stubble burning contributes to the Delhi Smog, the two events are almost always hyphenated in the public discourse, highlighting the former as primarily a public health issue rather than a farmers’ issue. The policy solutions have broadly taken the form of a ban on the practice, incentivising farmers to adopt new crop residue management systems, or fining them. This year, the challenges presented by the COVID-19 pandemic and farmers’ protests over the recent Farm Laws have amplified the impact of stubble burning and complicated the policy response.

This paper looks at stubble burning in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. It analyses the implementation of key policy measures undertaken over the years to address it, from a behavioural perspective of the farmer. It also assesses the scope for greater private sector engagement in abating stubble burning and suggests some policy actions towards the end.

CONTEXT: STUBBLE BURNING AMIDST THE PANDEMIC

Stubble burning has been a common way of managing crop residue in North India. However, over the last decade, owing to its linkage
with Delhi’s winter smog and increased media spotlight, the practice has invited various policy measures from State and Central governments. On the back of these policies, since 2016, Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh have witnessed a decrease in stubble burning events during the months of October and November (Figure 1 below).

Still, in 2018-19, Punjab and Haryana generated 28.10 million tons of paddy straw out of which 40.21% was burnt in the fields (Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare 2019: 56). While the number of burning events overall has gone down substantially, Punjab has seen a significant increase in such events in 2020. Figure 2 below shows that between 1 October and 28 October 2020, Punjab recorded 21,335 burning events, much higher than the number of burning events in 2018 and 2019 during the same time. This year, the discontent over the new Farm Laws has also become a key factor in the increase in burning events as farmer union leaders across Punjab have been reluctant to cooperate with the government (Jagga 2020).


Default Author Image

Akshita Sharma

Found this post insightful? Share it with your network and help spread the knowledge.

Suggested Reads

Macroeconomic Reforms and the Indian Manufacturing Sector: Locating Labour

Introduction In the May of 1990 when Montek Singh Ahluwalia delivered his seminal paper, “Towards a Restructuring of Industrial, Trade and Fiscal Policies” for an internal discussion in the government, a reservation on the question of labour was made for a later date, saying,  “Reforms relating to labour legislation are also necessary. However, this is […]

Women’s Healthcare: Budgeting and Policy Insights from Maharashtra and West Bengal

Introduction Throughout India’s history, both pre- and post-independence, Maharashtra and West Bengal have been leaders in advancing social reforms for women. Maharashtra’s contributions include the pioneering efforts of Jyotiba Phule and his wife Savitribai Phule, who broke societal barriers by establishing the first school for girls in Pune. Reformers like Dhondo Keshav Karve further pushed […]

Sexual Autonomy of Women in Rural India: Assessing SDG 5.6.1

Unfortunately, around 800,000 of these abortions are unsafe, contributing significantly to maternal mortality, despite the legal framework established by the Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) Act. This highlights the persistent barriers rural women face in accessing safe sexual health services, particularly due to inadequate healthcare infrastructure compared to urban areas. This indicator is a critical measure of gender equality and women’s empowerment, particularly in the context of sexual and reproductive health rights .

Great Nicobar Dilemma: Weighing Progress Against Preservation

Background  The Andaman and Nicobar Islands, a remote archipelago in the Bay of Bengal, are renowned for their pristine beaches, rich biodiversity and vibrant indigenous cultures. Much of the rich biodiversity has remained undiscovered in parts of the islands, and the fragile ecosystem faces significant environmental challenges.  The island of Great Nicobar, a part of […]