Challenges to Internal Security in India

Authored by: SPRF Research Team

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

The Internal Security of a nation-state can be understood as a concept relating to the apparatuses involved in securing its territorial boundaries and protecting its sovereignty. Given the multitude of religious, ethnic, regional and linguistic identities in India, internal security is a sine qua non. 

The  Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA),  in its annual report of 2017-18,  highlighted Organised Crimes on  Civilians, Left-Wing Extremism  (LWE), Cross-Border Terrorism in  Jammu and Kashmir (J&K), Militancy in the North-East, and Drugs and  Narcotics Trafficking, as formidable challenges to the country’s internal security. This paper also adds Environmental Degradation and Cyber Security to the above list.  This issue brief is first in the series on Internal Security and outlines an overview of each of the challenges.

INTRODUCTION

The Internal Security of a nation-state can be understood as a concept relating to the apparatuses involved in securing its territorial boundaries and protecting its sovereignty. These go hand in hand with the maintenance of peace, law and order, as well as the recognition that all citizens are equal before the overarching rule of law of the State (Singh 2016). The line between internal and national security is, however, contested. Samuel Makinda’s definition of security as “the preservation of the norms, rules, institutions and values of the society” is useful here (1998: 282). It connects sovereignty to security, while also highlighting that ‘Internal Security’  as a concept is very much outlined by the government in power at the time, and its geopolitical realities.  For a pluralistic context such as India with multiple religious,  ethnic, regional, and linguistic identities and a unique geopolitical position in the subcontinent,  internal security is a sine qua non  (Ganguly, et al: 2018). Given this,  as well as the understanding that  State and non-state actors may seek to destabilize the country,  India’s National Security Advisor, Ajit Doval, in an address to the  2014 batch of Indian Police Services  Probation Officers, noted, “We are now in the phase of fourth-generation warfare, a difficult war against an invisible army, whether it is organised crime,  terrorism, insurgency or foreign powers trying to meddle into your internal affairs.” (Doval: 2018). The  Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA)  has highlighted Organised Crimes on Civilians, Left-Wing Extremism  (LWE), Cross-Border Terrorism in Jammu and Kashmir (J&K),  Militancy in the North-East, and  Drugs and Narcotics Trafficking as prominent challenges for  India’s internal security apparatus in its Annual Report of 2017-18  (Ministry of Home Affairs 2018). Cyber Security Threats (which may severely disrupt India’s online ecosystems), and Environmental  Degradation (highlighted as possibly hampering ecological sustainability) have also emerged as the latest security challenges.

[ohio_button layout=”fill” shape_size=”large” shape_position=”left” full_width=”1″ icon_use=”1″ link=”url:/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/15.3.2019_Challenges-to-Internal-Security-in-Idnia.pdf|title:Read%20More” icon_as_icon=”linea-basic-eye” title_typo=”{“font_size“:““,“line_height“:““,“letter_spacing“:““,“color“:“#262626“,“weight“:“inherit“,“style“:“inherit“,“use_custom_font“:false}” title_typo_hover=”{“font_size“:““,“line_height“:““,“letter_spacing“:““,“color“:“#262626“,“weight“:“inherit“,“style“:“inherit“,“use_custom_font“:false}” color=”brand”]


Found this post insightful? Share it with your network and help spread the knowledge.

Suggested Reads

Workers or Owners? The Case of Women Farmers in India

Introduction Marginalization of women, seen through the case of exclusion from ownership structures, can be considered as one of the key reasons against which the suffrage movement was initially mounted, globally. However, in India and abroad, with the delinkages between citizenship rights and property holdings by the mid-twentieth century, the question of land rights and […]

बुलडोजर से अन्याय

आपराधिक मामलों के अभियुक्तों के मकान पर बुलडोजर चलाने की कार्रवाई ने देश के कानून के सामने नई चुनौती पेश की है। कानूनी प्रक्रिया का पालन किए बिना किसी की छत को कैसे ढहाया जा सकता है? अभियुक्त तो दूर यदि किसी को मुकदमे के बाद दोषी भी पाया गया है, तो क्या उसके मकान […]

Indian Exports Amid EU Deforestation Regulation

Among developed nations, the European Union (EU) has remained at the forefront of environmental protection, distinguished through proactive and legally binding measures. While many countries have set ambitious climate targets, the EU has gone a step further by enacting comprehensive policies that drive sustainable practices both within its borders and globally.   The European Green […]

India and Trump 2.0: Reciprocal Tariffs and the Case of India’s Manufacturing Exports

Disclaimer: This issue brief was written before the announcement of reciprocal tariffs by the new Trump administration on 2nd April, 2025, which imposed tariffs by a baseline of 10% for all countries exporting to the USA, and additional tariffs depending on their respective MFN tariff binds, with certain exempt commodities. For India, this amounts to […]