Ban on Conversion Therapy: All that needs to be done?

 

Context
The ban on conversion therapy needs a more comprehensive study to understand both its effect and efficacy. The provisions laid down by the court in S. Sushama v. Commissioner of Police, 2021 (HC 7284, 2021) only banned the medical practice of conversion therapy without criminalising the act of professing or practising the same. There are no punitive measures, and the practitioners of conversion therapy are only heard as professional misconduct cases, which culminate in a maximum punishment of being removed from the list of the National Health Commission. Even today, only roughly 600 courses are recognised by the same. 
While the judge did try to get a better understanding of the threat that looms over the homosexual body by appointing amicus curiae and recording these detailed ordeals and conversations within state documents, the knowledge of conversion therapy and the ordeal on the homosexual body by the structure fell short. Conversion Therapy must be understood as an umbrella term for all interventions that claim to be able to ‘pray the gay away’. This would mean a policy structure which recognises the various manifestations of conversion therapy, including de-addiction centres, Ayurveda, religious practices and other unregulated practices and their practitioners.
Conversion Therapy
Conversion Therapy, during its formulation, was constructed as a curative therapy standing on the two pillars of ‘being born as’ implying that the other body is a deviant and an abnormal body or socialisation ‘something made someone’ have deviant sexual preferences (Meyer & Lewin, 2002). Conversion therapy gradually became recognised as reparative therapy, a term still in use by the language of the Judgment in S. Sushama v. Commissioner of Police, 2021 (FirstPost, 2021). Conversion therapy is defined as “any emotional or physical therapy used to ‘cure’ a person’s attraction to the same sex, or their gender identity and expression. Providers claim these therapies can make someone heterosexual or ‘straight’.” (Sreenivas, S., 2021)
Straight Sex by M Canady eloquently explains that seeing sex as a binary of the male and female by the State is a tactical control to regulate, classify, recognise and punish deviant behaviour more easily. Family gives more accessible access to the individual’s body while keeping the rhetoric of freedom and autonomy alive. Skylar Coggswell-Shears has popularly pointed out that the LGBTQ body becomes the location to reset the gender binary and hence makes the task of disciplining more complex for the state.

 


Default Author Image

Research Desk

Found this post insightful? Share it with your network and help spread the knowledge.

Suggested Reads

अल्पसंख्यक शिक्षण संस्थान का दर्जा तय करने के लिए मापदंडों को उदार किया सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने 

अलीगढ़ मुस्लिम विश्वविद्यालय (एएमयू) के अल्पसंख्यक स्वरूप को लेकर लम्बे समय से चली आ रही कानूनी जंग अभी पूरी तरह खत्म नहीं हुई है। सुप्रीम कोर्ट की सात सदस्यीय संविधान पीठ ने 4:3 के बहुमत से साफतौर पर कहा कि संसद द्वारा पारित कानून का मतलब यह नहीं है कि उस शिक्षण संस्थान अपने अल्पसंख्यक […]

India vs. EU’s CBAM: Trade Wars & Green Tariffs

Introduction  The European Union has been at the forefront of global climate policy, aiming to achieve carbon neutrality by 2050 under its European Green Deal. To support this goal, the EU has introduced several measures, including the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM). The CBAM has been viewed as a key intervention to reduce carbon leakage. […]

Grid or Gaps? Exploring the Challenges of Rural Electrification in India Post-Saubhagya

Introduction  India has made significant strides in rural electrification, addressing energy poverty and its unique socio-economic development. In line with its global commitments to ‘ensuring access to affordable, reliable, and modern energy for all’, India led with key interventions, including the Pradhan Mantri Sahaj Bijli Har Ghar Yojana, also known as the Saubhagya Scheme. The […]

An Approximation of Employment-Centric Social Security Frameworks in India

The ongoing design process of the social security framework best suited to the platform-based gig economy in India is a testament to the changing terrain of increasingly complex industrial relations in India. At stake is the validity of the traditional tripartite model of industrial relations and a push for creative solutions.

Impact of the Agnipath Scheme on Indo-Nepal Relations, China’s Involvement, and Way Forward for India

Introduction The relations between South Asian countries are laden with historical complexities and shifting strategic concerns. India’s Agnipath scheme is a drastic change in military recruitment policy on the domestic and international levels. In this article, we will analyse the effects of the Agnipath scheme on Indo-Nepal relations, discuss the change in Nepal’s inclination towards […]